virgoreader asked:
What are your thoughts on Kally and Tanner from Fence? Would you ever include them in the traditional novels? 💕
I like Kally and Tanner a lot! Their devotion to each other is both tangled up with and what comes above fencing, and that’s beautiful, plus there’s family business, and that is my jam. So do I think that Kally and Tanner could play a major role or a significant minor role in a Fence novel? Definitely they have the potential.
I also think Eugene Labao has the potential for his own book, and Dante and Bobby, and hey, a story set at Exton would be awesome. But also, any and all of these storylines could and would be executed brilliantly in the graphic novels. And if these characters did star in Fence novels to come, they mightn’t necessarily be written by me.
I do want to stress when it comes to tie-in novels, while I do have a voice, ultimately it’s not up to me, and it shouldn’t be. Just like Claudia Gray doesn’t call all the Star Wars shots, and Leigh Bardugo doesn’t make the calls when it comes to Wonder Woman. (Though both of these ladies are great writers who make great narrative decisions!) We can make suggestions, but we are also open to re-direction on suggestions and when we receive a brief we act on it. So I’m not deciding for or against.
I think about my tie-in writing generally as a bit like being invited into a wonderful communal space, and being asked to decorate and transform some of the space into a new hang-out spot. I’m trying to use my own unique flair because I trust I was brought in for a reason, but it’s subject to approval. Usually tie-in novels tie in with visual media, and one thing you really have an opportunity for is a deep dive on the characters, what motivates their actions, and the secrets of their past and hearts. You consult everyone possible before you do that, but if the creator/director/script writer/showrunner thinks you got it wrong, you fix it. Even doing your best to fulfill everyone’s wishes, you know you can’t: other people already love the communal space and the characters and you’re going to step on someone’s head-canons. Which sucks, because they love the same characters you love!
Going into a deep-dive on some characters also may mean less room for other characters. Tie-in novels have length limits and are also written in a super compressed timeframe, even if you want to wax lyrical. Which I often do. And there’s structure to be considered, too. For instance, we didn’t get Seiji’s POV for a little while in Striking Distance not because I didn’t want to write it but because how Seiji is on the outside had to be impressed on the reader, before we got to the inside.
Tie-ins mean novels weaving in with another structure, as well as standing on their own. Nicholas is the protagonist of the Fence graphic novels and Seiji is his foil, and thus both must be important in any Fence property. And the structure of the graphic novels means the important matches which pave the way must be in there. Structurally, it’s time for more graphic novels/matches, and then who knows?
Also, Harvard and Aiden are pretty aligned with Kally and Tanner, and Harvard and Aiden shared the spotlight with Seiji and Nicholas in the duology of Striking Distance and Disarmed, which told an important story about them. But it’s all a balance–if I’d had more about Harvard and Aiden’s social circle as well as their emotional lives, that would’ve meant less time for Seiji and Nicholas and Eugene and their social circle, and I didn’t want to shortchange any of them. (I did experiment with adding Eugene PoV in Disarmed, but C.S. Pacat and I decided it would add time and length, and make it less of a whole with Striking Distance.) Plus, Harvard and Aiden are the older ones on the team, and at an emotional place where some emotional realisations and revelations could occur, so this was the place in the story for that. Whereas say, Eugene may need some more matches until he reaches a place for emotional revelations.
As regards the person writing them, the timing might be tricky for me–I have to watch my health and I would never want to give less than the best I could due to haste. However there are several writers I can think of off the top of my head who are magnificently speedy and would write amazing novels for the Fence characters, and some of those writers might suit certain potential Fence stories, or Fence fans, better than I do! Generally I’ve been so glad to receive love for the novels from Fence fandom, and I think Fence fandom is lovely and has been lovely to me, but I know not everyone likes my writing. It would be awesome if everybody in the world did, but let’s be real, not everyone in the world likes cheese so I have no chance. I try not to say self-deprecatory things about myself anymore (used to be very good at it, not to brag), so let me state here that I am a jewel–but some people prefer emeralds to rubies, and that’s okay! I wish them emeralds. And if the timing did work out, I’d try to be emeraldesque for them as well as rubies for those who like my rubies, but if not, awesome emeralds might happen. Or exclusively C.S. Pacat’s graphic novels, telling a diamond tale.
In any case, I believe there are wonderful things ahead for the Fence fandom, and like Tanner with Kally, I’ll always be cheering you on.
In summary: my thoughts are positive and I might. These things are complex! So sorry for rattling on. Thank you for asking a lovely question and showing Kally and Tanner much-deserved love. <3